A DUAL OUTCOME FRAMEWORK FOR EVALUATING COOPERATIVE MICROCREDIT RELATIONSHIPS
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.24071/icebmr.v5i1.376Keywords:
business success, loan repayment performance, dual outcome frameworkAbstract
The concept of microcredit success remains contested despite five decades of microfinance research and practice. Existing studies use diverse outcomes to define success, with the issue becoming more complex in cooperative microcredit, where members are simultaneously owners, savers, borrowers, and voters. This article develops a dual outcome framework combining business success at the member level and loan repayment performance at the member–cooperative relationship. The study integrates evidence from four microfinance handbooks and literature on credit constraints, financial intermediation, development economics, cooperative finance, and construct measurement. Four criteria guide the selection of outcomes: their correspondence with the member’s dual identity, the possibility that outcomes diverge, their role in sustaining the credit cycle, and their feasibility of measurement at cooperative scale. The analysis identifies business success and loan repayment performance as distinct but complementary outcomes. Loan repayment performance is necessary for sustaining intermediation but does not by itself indicate business success, while neither outcome can serve as a proxy for the other. The framework therefore evaluates both outcomes separately rather than combining them into a compensatory index. It proposes a four-quadrant typology to guide future analysis on cooperative microcredit success.
Downloads
Downloads
Published
Issue
Section
License
Copyright (c) 2026 Stephanus Eri Kusuma (Author)

This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.